+- BAJR Federation Archaeology (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk)
+-- Forum: BAJR Federation Forums (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: The Site Hut (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: Druids and Avebury Reburial (/showthread.php?tid=1272)
Druids and Avebury Reburial - the invisible man - 21st July 2009
Ah, at last, some well reasoned common sense, calmly, coherently and concisely argued! It'll never catch on!
Druids and Avebury Reburial - oldgirl - 21st July 2009
Quote:quote:Originally posted by the invisible man
Ah, at last, some well reasoned common sense, calmly, coherently and concisely argued! It'll never catch on!
Don't quite know what came over me..... [:p]
Druids and Avebury Reburial - Oddie - 22nd July 2009
Oldgirl - Equality in Law and equality in ethics of place, yes.
Do you fear that reburial will take precedent over musologists et al? Such fear is unfounded. The argument does indeed lean equally both ways, but up to now, the ancestors haven?t had a say.
Our ancestral remains belong in the earth and not on display (or on any butchers block) and are not present simply to remind you that real people live and die. It may be argued that current environmental disaster has its roots in sedentary living - but that's another discussion for another day I guess, and we don?t really need to face the body naked to understand ourselves. Reburial does not seek to re-invent a past (unlike much processual interpretation) rather, spirituality express a present. O the odd
Got a new-ish engine, but now need a crane, scrap merchant and Brutish Waterways off me back
Oddie
Druids and Avebury Reburial - amiable drudge - 23rd July 2009
Quote:quote:Originally posted by Oddie
the ancestors haven?t had a say.
you don't suppose that that's because they're, like, dead and gone? and they ain't coming back. and you ARE re-inventing the past.
your self-appointed whiny victimhood is starting to be not funny any more.
and you're starting to add banal footnotes that point to a persecution complex.
but i think it was Hunter S Thompson, in 'Hells Angels', who quoted the fact that, merely because a group is persecuted, it doesn't necessarily imbue them with special virtues.
you can't win here, Oddie, call it a day and walk away.
edit
added bile
Druids and Avebury Reburial - Oddie - 23rd July 2009
<post removed>
Oddie
Druids and Avebury Reburial - Bier Keller - 23rd July 2009
My ancestors live in the world around me, in the hedgerow, in the blackbird hunting worms in the morning, in the wind that blows through the trees. they don't talk to me about the bones I regularly disturb in the course of my work.
Tell me Oddie that somehow "your" ancestors are somehow "better" than "my" ancestors, or better than anybody elses who has looked at this thread. Tell me and explain why, your POV/"your" ancestors POV is more valid than mine.
It'll never happen
Beer is your friend
Druids and Avebury Reburial - Oddie - 24th July 2009
please replace my removed postings you f*****rs
Oddie
Druids and Avebury Reburial - the invisible man - 24th July 2009
To state the obvious, how does one know that these remains are those of one's ancestors? Predecessors living on this fair if damp island, certainly, and by the very nature of things any one prehistoric individual may well be AN ancestor of a very large number of present-day Britons.
In short, the deceased in question may not be an ancestor of yours, Oddity, and is just as likely to be an ancestor of mine. I hereby give full permission for my deceased relative's remains to be examined for study and the enhancement of human knowledge and understanding.
Druids and Avebury Reburial - Gog - 24th July 2009
Quote:quote:Originally posted by Oddie
please replace my removed postings you f*****rs
Oddie
Tut tut - such aggression. Very Roman.
Druids and Avebury Reburial - BAJR Host - 25th July 2009
You will be pleased to know that druid oddie has now being barred.. use of language, offensive comments (deleted) and an inability to discuss, which involves listening to the oher side in order to be informed, rather than having a point of view, and sticking to it... while suggesting this is a debate.
and so farewell to the longest thread ... sorely unmissed! :face-huh:
Constant development is the law of life, and a man who always tries to maintain his dogmas in order to appear consistent drives himself into a false position.
Mohandas Gandhi