+- BAJR Federation Archaeology (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk)
+-- Forum: BAJR Federation Forums (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: The Site Hut (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: Community Archaeology. (/showthread.php?tid=832)
Community Archaeology. - BAJR Host - 20th February 2008
While I'm in the mood for presenting articles :
This one was written to reply to the Opinion in Current Archaeology 213 - concerning how Community Archaeology is not being supported by Curatorial Staff...
It was with great interest that I read the article in current archaeology 213 last month on ?Community archaeology-against the odds?.
As a development control archaeologist working within a council I was not surprised at the initial reaction to the opinions of the authors. There was anger at what was seen to be an ill-informed point of view with sweeping generalisations and a somewhat vague grasp on contract archaeology. Suggesting that ?..most excavations were very small evaluation trenches dug by hand to a shallow depth and that is the primary objective was a collection of artefacts rather than features..?, which was, to say the least, baffling.
I expect that there will be a number of replies from curators and contractors letting off steam, in the general direction of this article. Many will say that there is a great deal of archaeology taking place within the community, and that they can name several projects in the area, they may also say that the authors only had to ask to find out what was going on around the UK.
Curators are singled out as providing little support to local groups, however they are inhibited by budgetary constraints on time and resources.
From a certain angle however the authors are right, there is a lack of easily accessible guides and templates to enable local groups to begin, and I stress begin, an archaeological project.
They do exist, and in Scotland we are in some ways blessed by what could be described as a template for just such a requirement.
Scotland's Rural Past is an exemplar five year project which supports local committees across Scotland to investigate deserted rural settlements. The website provides a portal from dozens of project groups to communicate and access essential information, including templates and recording, notes on reporting, photography, survey and a host of other useful skills. This empowers people to be both independent and to easily access the contact details of useful groups and individuals that they may need to take a project from an idea to a reality.
Alongside this the Council for Scottish Archaeology (CSA) has an adopt-a-monument officer, Helen Bradley, who provides practical advice and training to volunteer groups to improve the condition accessibility and even interpretation of a site that they chose. I like to see Helen as a Finds Liaison Officer for sites, and personally believe that there should not be just one but ten such officers across Scotland, to support local people who care about their own local archaeology.
In Perth & Kinross, the ceaseless work of the Heritage Trust has turned an archaeology week in 2003 into an archaeology month, due to increased popularity and demand with many local and national organisations now joining to create an international event in a local scale, and includes excavations at several sites across the county with many volunteer opportunities available.
In my own county, and taking the view that this is a local project for local people we have the Prestongrange project, with a large waiting list of people looking to participate in a remarkable venture that ranges from excavation of industrial remains through to oral history and educational spin-offs. It may not make the national headlines, but the dedication of both the professional archaeologists and volunteers makes this a special event for the people of Prestonpans.
The point I'm trying to make, is that there is a lot going on and that there are resources available. Some events and projects are known across the country, while others are designed to be local events - and to suggest there is somehow a link between commercial archaeology and public archaeology and that the former is somehow impacting upon the latter is nonsense.
What is clear, is a need for public archaeology, and a need for easily accessible information on who to talk to, how to carry out the work, where to get funding from, who to get help from, how to report?. etc and rather than attacking county archaeologists, we should be looking at the real causes such as lack of funding for HERs and a reliance on goodwill to get projects going, the article took potshots at the wrong people, but it does make us confront what is happening and how we can make it more accessible.
A simple Guide to starting a project would be a first step, and the first step all should take, is contacting the local council archaeologist, who can inform the group about possibilities and available resources. Perhaps we should also be asking the people what they want, and contact local groups across the UK to ask opinions. Public Archaeology is essential for the continued support of the community as a whole for archaeology in general, if anything, although wide of the mark in some respects, this article focused our attention on what is an important subject.
Scotland?s Rural Past: http://www.scotlandsruralpast.org.uk/
Adopt a Monument: http://www.scottisharchaeology.org.uk/projects/adopt.html
Shorewatch http://www.scapetrust.org/html/shorewatch.html
Perth & Kinross Heritage Trust: http://www.pkht.org.uk/Events.asp?id=7
Prestongrange Community Archaeological Project http://www.prestongrange.org/pcap/
"No job worth doing was ever done on time or under budget.."
Khufu
Community Archaeology. - Curator Kid - 20th February 2008
I was rather bored to note that three issues after the original drivelling article, CA printed only one response - and even that was followed by the authors being allowed their final twopenn'orth on the issue. :face-confused:
Community Archaeology. - historic building - 20th February 2008
I think we all know that current archaeology is about as fair and balanced as the daily mail.
Community Archaeology. - Winders - 20th February 2008
There are times where I think Current Archaeology is the archaeological equivalent of the Daily Mail...
Community Archaeology. - BAJR Host - 20th February 2008
well ... now you can at least see one of a few replies that did not make it
This was written with consultation - so hopefully was as balanced as it could be. More guardian than Mail :face-huh:
Shame that a debate started, was not allowed to flourish... bit like throwing a brick through a window.. then runnign off!
"No job worth doing was ever done on time or under budget.."
Khufu
Community Archaeology. - Curator Kid - 20th February 2008
Hmmm. Not sure the original article was even intended to be the start of a debate? All I read was a lot of inadequately-researched and ill-informed effluvia. Hardly the sort of thing that warranted the effort of compiling a well researched and balanced response. Presumably that was not what CA wanted either, since they didn't print yours Mr. Hosty...
Community Archaeology. - Oxbeast - 20th February 2008
We could always invite the authors over here. Or I see that one of the authors has a website of his own, http://www.badarchaeology.net
It was certainly an interesting piece, and suggested that the background of the people involved was neither in field archaeology nor in community archaeology. Shame that the piece is not still on the net.
Community Archaeology. - BAJR Host - 20th February 2008
East Lothian Council and the Council for Scottish Archaeology will host a Scottish Community Archaeology Conference in East Lothian in February 2009. Bringing groups from all over Scotland to share info and skills.!
I suppose I may as well plug my own one at Cousland... scores of people over a week - March April this year... fieldwalking.. survey, building record, excavation, research, you name it!
Plus a whole county Audit for access to sites...
ah well.... we do try... though are seldom appreciated!
"No job worth doing was ever done on time or under budget.."
Khufu
Community Archaeology. - BAJR Host - 21st February 2008
Anyone care to come and reply from the original authors? One hopes they feel strongly enough to be able to defend the position.?
"No job worth doing was ever done on time or under budget.."
Khufu