28th December 2005, 01:36 PM
I agree in principle, but there are some significant problems with this approach. My comments below are also points of general principle, not an argument for quarrying at Thornborough, but they do need to be taken into account in any decision on quarrying.
Gravel - ok, gravel companies can go elsewhere (but only where there is gravel available). Suitable gravel is not as common as you might think, and quite a lot of it is not available (eg because its been built on). While we gain access to it through profit-driven commercial exploitation, it is nevertheless a strategic resource without which the nation's economy would grind to a halt.
Farming - well, the farmer(s) concerned only own a certain amount of land in certain locations. If you say 'this land has been farmed for generations, but now you have to stop', then you are taking away their livelihood. They can't even sell it and buy land elsewhere, because you have taken the value out of their land by ensuring that the buyer could neither farm, nor quarry, nor develop. A bit harsh on farmer to throw them out and potentially make them destitute! (might or might not be the effect in this particular case, but the principle must apply universally or not at all).
1man1desk
to let, fully furnished
Gravel - ok, gravel companies can go elsewhere (but only where there is gravel available). Suitable gravel is not as common as you might think, and quite a lot of it is not available (eg because its been built on). While we gain access to it through profit-driven commercial exploitation, it is nevertheless a strategic resource without which the nation's economy would grind to a halt.
Farming - well, the farmer(s) concerned only own a certain amount of land in certain locations. If you say 'this land has been farmed for generations, but now you have to stop', then you are taking away their livelihood. They can't even sell it and buy land elsewhere, because you have taken the value out of their land by ensuring that the buyer could neither farm, nor quarry, nor develop. A bit harsh on farmer to throw them out and potentially make them destitute! (might or might not be the effect in this particular case, but the principle must apply universally or not at all).
1man1desk
to let, fully furnished